Blog

We scanned 2,423 Shopify stores. Nearly 1 in 5 had something broken that shoppers could see.

In November 2026 we scanned 2,423 live US Shopify stores from a commercial store database for problems a shopper could run into on the storefront. Not speed scores, not SEO. Just: does every link go somewhere, does every collection have products in it, is there leftover demo text on the homepage.

At least 455 of them, 19%, had one or more. 7% had two or more separate problems. Across those 455 stores we counted 802 broken things, 1.8 per store, because one store can have more than one of the same kind, like two dead links.

As far as we can tell, nothing in the Shopify admin flags any of these. The owner finds out when a customer mentions it, if one ever does.

Here's what we found, how common each one was, and how to check your own store for it.

The numbers

Problem a shopper can seeStoresShare
Menu link opens a collection with no products1787%
Menu link goes to a page that doesn't exist1105%
Shopify's placeholder text left on the homepage582%
Footer link goes to a page that doesn't exist462%
Social icon points to a default URL, not the store's account442%
3 or more products with no photo402%
Homepage button or link goes to a page that doesn't exist372%
At least one of the above45519%
Two or more separate problems1607%

A store counts once per row, and one store can appear in several rows, so the rows don't add up to 19%. The three dead-link rows overlap as well, so they can't be added together.

We say "at least" because the scan looks at up to 30 links, 6 menu collections and 4 pages of products per store, so it can miss things. We say "a shopper could see" because every problem had to fail on two checks about 12 hours apart, and was then confirmed in a real browser. Hidden menu items and theme leftovers nobody can reach aren't counted.

The most common problem we found. A shopper taps a collection in your menu and lands on a page with nothing for sale on it.

How it happens: a collection can empty out without anyone touching the menu. An automated collection stops matching when a tag, product type or other condition changes. A manual collection goes empty when its products are deleted, set to draft, or taken off the Online Store sales channel. The menu link stays where it was.

Check it: open your store on your phone and tap every item in your main menu, including the ones inside dropdowns. Any collection page with no products on it is this.

Fix it: put products back, or take the link out. For the first, open the collection in Products, then Collections, check its conditions or its product list, and make sure those products are active and available on the Online Store channel. For the second, remove the item in Content, then Menus.

A menu item points at an address that no longer leads anywhere. The shopper gets a "page not found" screen.

How it happens: the address the menu item points at changed, and the menu item didn't. Shopify's own help page on editing menus warns that changing a URL "can disrupt the connection to the menu item and lead to a 404 error." Links that were typed or pasted in as a web address are the easy ones to break, because nothing ties them to the page they were meant for.

Check it: the same walk through the menu as above. This time you're looking for "404" or "page not found."

Fix it: in Content, then Menus, open the menu and point the item at the right page. If the old address was shared anywhere, like an ad, an email or a social post, also add a redirect so those visitors land somewhere useful. That's in Content, then Menus, then View URL redirects.

3. Shopify's placeholder text is still on the homepage (2%)

The sample copy a theme ships with, still on the live homepage. Lines like "Talk about your brand" or "Share information about your brand with your customers."

How it happens: the theme got set up, the top of the homepage got real content, and a section further down was never opened.

Check it: scroll your homepage all the way to the bottom on your phone and read every heading. If one of them sounds like it was written for no store in particular, it was.

Fix it: in Online Store, then Themes, then Customize, open the section and either write real copy or remove the section. Removing it is fine.

The same problem as number 2, in the footer, which is where the shipping, returns and contact links usually live.

Check it: tap every link in your footer.

Fix it: the footer is a menu too, so it's edited in Content, then Menus. Point the link at the right page or remove it. If a policy link is the dead one, check that the policy has been filled in under Settings, then Policies.

5. A social icon points at a default URL (2%)

The social icon on your store opens the platform's homepage or an example account instead of your profile.

How it happens: the social links live in the theme settings. If a field still holds the value it came with, the icon shows up and works. It just goes to the wrong place.

Check it: tap each social icon on your store and make sure it opens your account.

Fix it: in Online Store, then Themes, then Customize, open Theme settings and find the social media section. Put your real profile addresses in and clear the fields for platforms you're not on.

6. Three or more products with no photo (2%)

Products live on the storefront with a blank or placeholder image where the photo should be.

How it happens: products were added before the photos were ready, or brought in from somewhere else and the images didn't come with them.

Check it: go to yourstore.com/collections/all, which lists every product, and scroll through it on your phone.

Fix it: add the photo, or set the product to draft until you have one.

7. A homepage button goes to a page that doesn't exist (2%)

A button or link on the homepage, often the big one on the main banner, points at something that isn't there any more.

How it happens: the same as the menu links. The button was set once, and the page it pointed at changed.

Check it: tap every button and link on your homepage.

Fix it: in Customize, open the section the button is in and point it at the right page.

Why you don't hear about any of this

The admin shows you what's happening inside the admin. It doesn't walk your storefront the way a shopper does, tapping every link and opening every collection.

So the check that catches these is the one you do yourself, on a phone, tapping everything. Do it after any change that removes or renames something, and every so often regardless.

About the sample

These are 2,423 live US Shopify stores from a commercial store database, scanned in November 2026. "US" means the store's Shopify market is set to the US, or not set at all. Stores selling to another market were left out before the count, and so were stores that had already closed: 93 of the 2,989 stores we scanned, 3%, were showing Shopify's "store unavailable" page.

It isn't a random sample of every Shopify store, and these aren't numbers for the whole platform. They're stores we hadn't looked at before, with EU domains removed.

Want this handled on your store? Four packages, each with a fixed price and a written scope before you pay.

Get a free auditSee the packages